BALLADEX
Balladex/NFL/Compare/Arian Smith vs Luke McCaffrey
Arian Smith
50IMPACT
Arian Smith
New York Jets · Wide Receiver
Luke McCaffrey
50IMPACT
Luke McCaffrey
Washington Commanders · Wide Receiver
VS
1–3
categories
McCaffrey leads the head-to-head, 3 categories to 1.
Rebuildvs
Tale of the tape
7
Receptions (career)
29
52
Receiving yards (career)
371
7.4
Yards per catch
18.5
16
Targets (season)
15
The verdict

McCaffrey holds the edge, leading in 3 of 4 categories (receptions (career), receiving yards (career), yards per catch). Smith answers in targets (season) — which is exactly why this is the marquee debate.

50Smith · Rotation piece
Balladex Impact Index
50McCaffrey · Rotation piece

Card value — head to head

Arian Smith
$1.0
Blue-chip — stable star value
5-yr outlook+0%
Legacy floor100%
Luke McCaffrey
$1.0
Climbing
5-yr outlook+100% ▲
Legacy floor100%
Card verdictBoth grade to about $1.0 today. Luke McCaffrey carries more projected upside (+100% vs. +0% over five years).
← Arian Smith's pageAll comparisonsLuke McCaffrey's page →