Who is better, Anthony Richardson Sr. or J.J. McCarthy?

Balladex/NFL/Compare/Anthony Richardson Sr. vs J.J. McCarthy

Anthony Richardson Sr. vs J.J. McCarthy: head-to-head statistical comparison

50IMPACT

Anthony Richardson Sr.

Indianapolis Colts · Quarterback

50IMPACT

J.J. McCarthy

New York Giants · Quarterback

1–3

categories

McCarthy leads the head-to-head, 3 categories to 1.

Rebuildvs

Tale of the tape

2,400

Passing yards (career)

1,875

Passing TDs (career)

62.5

Passer rating

90.0

50.0

Completion %

52.4

Interceptions (career)

The verdict

McCarthy holds the edge, leading in 3 of 5 categories (passing tds, passer rating, completion %). Sr. answers in passing yards — which is exactly why this is the marquee debate.

50Sr. · Rotation piece

Balladex Impact Index

50McCarthy · Rotation piece

Card value — head to head

Anthony Richardson Sr.

$5.0

Climbing

5-yr outlook+20%

Legacy floor100%

J.J. McCarthy

$5.0

Climbing

5-yr outlook+20%

Legacy floor100%

Card verdictBoth grade to about $5.0 today.

← Anthony Richardson Sr.'s page All comparisons J.J. McCarthy's page →