Balladex/NFL/Compare/Charlie Smyth vs Trey Smack

Charlie Smyth vs Trey Smack: head-to-head statistical comparison

Charlie Smyth

New Orleans Saints · Kicker

Trey Smack

Green Bay Packers · Kicker

VS

3–0

categories

Smyth leads the head-to-head, 3 categories to 0.

Rebuildvs

Tale of the tape

12

Field goals made (career)

6

49

Points (career)

25

13

Extra points made (career)

7

The verdict

Smyth holds the edge, leading in 3 of 3 categories (field goals made, points, extra points made). Smack answers in the intangibles — which is exactly why this is the marquee debate.

50Smyth · Rotation piece

Balladex Impact Index

50Smack · Rotation piece

Card value — head to head

Charlie Smyth

$1.0

Blue-chip — stable star value

5-yr outlook+0%

Legacy floor100%

Trey Smack

$1.0

Blue-chip — stable star value

5-yr outlook+0%

Legacy floor100%

Card verdictBoth grade to about $1.0 today.

← Charlie Smyth's page All comparisons Trey Smack's page →