BALLADEX
Balladex/NFL/Compare/J.J. McCarthy vs Jameis Winston
J.J. McCarthy
50IMPACT
J.J. McCarthy
New York Giants · Quarterback
Jameis Winston
50IMPACT
Jameis Winston
New York Giants · Quarterback
VS
2–3
categories
Winston leads the head-to-head, 3 categories to 2.
Rebuildvs
Tale of the tape
1,632
Passing yards (career)
25,271
11
Passing TDs (career)
159
72.6
Passer rating
70.4
57.6
Completion %
55.1
12
Interceptions (career)
116
The verdict

Winston holds the edge, leading in 3 of 5 categories (passing yards (career), passing tds (career), interceptions (career)). McCarthy answers in passer rating, completion % — which is exactly why this is the marquee debate.

50McCarthy · Rotation piece
Balladex Impact Index
50Winston · Rotation piece

Card value — head to head

J.J. McCarthy
$3.0
Climbing
5-yr outlook+33% ▲
Legacy floor100%
Jameis Winston
$13
Climbing
5-yr outlook+23%
Legacy floor100%
RarityRare
Card verdictJameis Winston is the more valuable card today ($13 vs. $3.0). J.J. McCarthy carries more projected upside (+33% vs. +23% over five years).
← J.J. McCarthy's pageAll comparisonsJameis Winston's page →