J.J. McCarthy
Tanner McKee
VS
4–1
categories
McCarthy leads the head-to-head, 4 categories to 1.
Rebuildvs
Tale of the tape
1,632
597
11
5
72.6
73.2
57.6
55.8
12
1
The verdict
McCarthy holds the edge, leading in 4 of 5 categories (passing yards (career), passing tds (career), completion %). McKee answers in passer rating — which is exactly why this is the marquee debate.
50McCarthy · Rotation piece
Balladex Impact Index
50McKee · Rotation piece
Card value — head to head
J.J. McCarthy
$3.0
Climbing
5-yr outlook+33% ▲
Legacy floor100%
Tanner McKee
$4.0
Climbing
5-yr outlook+25%
Legacy floor100%
Card verdictTanner McKee is the more valuable card today ($4.0 vs. $3.0). J.J. McCarthy carries more projected upside (+33% vs. +25% over five years).