Gibbens leads in 3 of 4 categories (tackles, sacks, passes defended); the other one is tied, so Speights wins none.
Who has more tackles, Jack Gibbens or Omar Speights?
Jack Gibbens: 290 to Omar Speights's 178 (Tackles (career)).
Who has more sacks, Jack Gibbens or Omar Speights?
Jack Gibbens: 3.0 to Omar Speights's 2.0 (Sacks (career)).
How does Balladex decide who wins?
Each shared stat is a category; the player ahead in more of them leads. Here that is 3–0 with 1 tied. Stats and awards are real; the verdict is arithmetic on them, not an opinion.